Paper, Plastic or Hermes?

Read this uncredited AP article today and realized what a wonderful, completely conflicted society we live in. I can’t qualify that completely with what I am about to write but I’ll try my darnedest to do just that.
The article in question addresses a new trend in which grocery shoppers are bringing their own designer bags to store their items as opposed to using simple paper or plastic. Now on any other cheery, bubblegum blog you would find someone applauding and delighting in this trend and using words like “fashionista” to explain the “fabulous” people that carry these bags. Problem is, I don’t do bubblegum.
The green and environmental activist in me applauds this development. No more cutting down trees to store my food. No more using plastics that eventually end up in the ocean miles away, choking innocent dolphins. But I find it hard to reconcile that with spending at least $1,000 for a Hermes bag that is “Made of hand-wrought silk” and “collapses into a wallet-size pouch of calfskin”. I guess I’m not sold on paying that much for a bag just to store items that will make a mess of it (slimy vegetables anyone?). So it breaks down into two problems: problem 1, it is $1,000; problem 2, some animal still had to die for my groceries. Thus the aforementioned societal conflict rears its’ ugly head.
Stella McCartney’s got the right idea though. The article states that she has an organic canvas shopper for $495. A little bit more manageable and I’ll be less at odds with my environmental activism than purchasing some Hermes bag that will end up storing cabbage.
Here’s how the article ends:
“This month’s Vogue magazine urges fashionistas to become more bag-wise: ‘No loitering, girls,’ says contributing editor Sarah Mower. ‘Today, let us go out and harness the power of fashion to change the way the nation shops.’
ugh.
Read the full article here.
18 Comments to Paper, Plastic or Hermes?
I know you’re supposed to be green but Eva, I love the Hermes leather bag pictured. Where can I get it?
May 10, 2007
[...] Read this uncredited AP article today and realized what a wonderful, completely conflicted society we live in. I can’t qualify that completely with what I am about to write but I’ll try my darnedest…[read] [...]
May 10, 2007
It seems absurd that you would get a designer bag to go grocery shopping.
May 10, 2007
A $50,000 Birkin bag. Now that’s ridiculous
May 11, 2007
[...] Papierblog Are [reusable designer shopping bags] truly the future? Papierblog finds out. [...]
[...] life a little more manageable. Girlawhirl finds options from Alexandra Bee and Purseket… Are reusable designer shopping bags truly the future? Papierblog finds out… Second City Style interviews Project Runway winner, [...]
[...] reusable designer shopping bags truly the future? Papierblog finds [...]
[...] reusable designer shopping bags truly the future? Papierblog finds [...]
[...] reusable designer shopping bags truly the future? Papierblog finds [...]
May 14, 2007
Where are you buying slimy vegetables? You need a better place to shop!
I wonder… if you can afford spending a thousand dollars on a glorified grocery bag, are you really the one doing your own grocery shopping?
That said, I love the idea of bringing your own grocery bag to the store. Can’t go wrong with a monogrammed L.L. Bean tote. Crisp, clean and classically preppy.
May 15, 2007
I like to use random canvas bags that I can throw in the washing machine if anything messy leaks. See http://shesabetty.typepad.com/shes_a_betty_single_girl_/2007/04/guide_to_reusab.html for another take on this topic.
If you’re going to spend, it should be on a conceptual piece like Martin Margiela’s bag that actually is styled exactly like a plastic bag…a far more subtle piece than Hindmarch’s “This is not a plastic bag” or whatever it was. But to her credit, Hindmarch’s bag only costs $15.
Here’s an interesting thought, Eva: there is a bag company called Entermodal that set out to build the most sustainable bag business. They considered canvas, but eventually decided on leather. The main reason? It lasts the longest. They found vintage leather doctor bags from 1850 and decided that they want to make a bag that will last 50 years with the thought that all of the environmental costs that go into making one bag would only have to be incurred once every fifty years, rather than once a year. They don’t make shoppers, but it’s an interesting consideration.
Hell with it. I’m just going to sew massive pockets into all my dresses and shove the groceries in there for the trip home. Beat that.
Look up getskn.com This new modern design co. has a graphic printed designer cloth shopping bag for $19.95 called “The Carrot Bag”. Its purpose is to bring high-end design to the eco-chic market, but at a price most can afford. After all , the point is to make an impact on the environment, not just an impact on rodeo drive!
The other option is EnviroSax bags which are fashionable and no where near the price tag of these mentioned designs. In my shopping world practicality is the key.
I found these bags at shop.bangalla.com - cool Australian products.
You can have a stylish reusable shopping bag at a more reasonable price than the Hermes. One option is a bag from http://www.myownbag.com
These bags are stylish, strong, lightweight and fold for storage in that other more expensive bag. You can use it for groceries and shopping at your local boutique.
I make these bags in San Francisco, with local labor. I love fashion and a clean environment, so these bags are the combination of both of my passions. Hope you enjoy them ladies.
November 27, 2007
I’m happy to see this - I thought it would be a great business idea! (Except I lack the ability to sew.) While most normal people wouldn’t pay the $5000 for a name brand bag, this could become a great trend to encourage greener shopping habits. And no doubt, as this trend grows, there’s no better marketing in America than seeing a celebrity weilding a name-brand shopping bag for everyday grocery shopping. If they say its fashionable, soon fashion-forward Americans will be too (most for a lot less $ of course).
Of course, it is ideal that all these bags be made of eco-friendly materials, but if marketed right could be a great trend for America. I hope it sticks.
The post above by Ania has some beautiful bags for a much more reasonable price.
I’m just sad I didn’t think of it first! ![]()
…or canvas? Click on to see http://www.miamuratori.com/index.php?option=com_rsgallery2&Itemid=26&catid=4
Leave a comment
Search
The Magazine

Papierdoll September 2008 Foto Story
Seance
photography Anne-Marie Michel
Fashion is haunted by trends of seasons past. Normally you’ll find yourself wincing at old photos from an earlier decade when shoulder pads were in. Bell bottoms are now the thing as illustrated by our retro article this month.... [Go]
Recent Talk
cess oliva: these girls rock!!Michel Kerkes: I love Calvin Klein and
Fashion Week - Megan Crook (via cellphone) |: [...] talking about the International
Burberry sales are up while everyone else is down - sexy fashion blog: [...] Via Papierblog. [...]
Karen: she looks like a dolphin

May 10, 2007